Cash Buyer vs. Realtor: Which Is the Right Way to Sell Your PA House?
An honest, side-by-side comparison from a local cash buyer who'll tell you when we're NOT your best option.
Get Your No-Obligation Cash OfferThe Honest Truth: Neither Option Is Always Better
Most comparison pages you'll find online are written by cash buyers trying to convince you to sell to them, or by agents trying to justify their commission. We're going to give you the real picture.
I'm Tyler Swenson, founder of ClearEdge Home Buyers. I've purchased over 200 homes across Eastern Pennsylvania since 2016. I've also referred homeowners to realtors when that was genuinely the better path. Here's the truth: the right choice depends on your property's condition, your timeline, your financial situation, and your tolerance for the traditional selling process.
This guide breaks down both options honestly so you can make the decision that's right for you.
One thing worth knowing upfront: cash sales are more common than most people think. According to the National Association of Realtors, nearly 1 in 3 home sales in late 2025 were all-cash transactions — the highest rate in over a decade. Meanwhile, 91% of sellers still use a real estate agent. Both paths work. The question is which one works for YOUR situation.
Cash Buyer vs. Realtor: The Full Comparison
| Factor | Cash Buyer | Realtor |
|---|---|---|
| Timeline to Close | 7–30 days | 60–120+ days |
| Repairs Required | None — sell 100% as-is | $10,000–$30,000+ typically |
| Commissions & Fees | $0 | 5.81% avg in PA (~$16K on $280K home) |
| Showings | One visit from our team | Dozens of showings, open houses |
| Certainty of Sale | Guaranteed — no financing contingencies | 15–20% fall through |
| Sale Price | Below market value (we're transparent) | Potentially full market value |
| Out-of-Pocket Costs | $0 | Repairs, staging, carrying costs, commissions |
| Inspections / Appraisals | None required | Can derail deals |
| Negotiation | One straightforward offer | Back-and-forth, potential price reductions |
| Privacy | Completely private | Public listing with photos online |
| Stress Level | Minimal — one point of contact | Can be significant |
Timeline to Close
Cash Buyer
7–30 days
Realtor
60–120+ days
Repairs Required
Cash Buyer
None — sell 100% as-is
Realtor
$10K–$30K+ typically
Commissions & Fees
Cash Buyer
$0
Realtor
5.81% avg in PA
Showings
Cash Buyer
One visit from our team
Realtor
Dozens of showings
Certainty of Sale
Cash Buyer
Guaranteed
Realtor
15–20% fall through
Sale Price
Cash Buyer
Below market value
Realtor
Potentially full value
Out-of-Pocket Costs
Cash Buyer
$0
Realtor
Repairs, staging, commissions
Privacy
Cash Buyer
Completely private
Realtor
Public listing online
When You Should List with a Realtor
A traditional listing with a realtor is likely your best option if:
Your home is in good, move-in-ready condition.
If your property doesn't need major repairs and shows well, you'll likely get the highest price by exposing it to the open market. Well-maintained homes in desirable Eastern PA neighborhoods are selling quickly — in the Lehigh Valley, move-in ready homes sell in about 22 days at or above asking price. NEPA's hottest markets like Scranton see well-priced homes go in under 10 days.
You have time to wait.
The traditional process typically takes 60 to 120 days from listing to closing. If you're not under time pressure, this timeline allows for maximum market exposure and competitive offers.
You want to maximize sale price above all else.
Cash buyers need to account for repair costs, carrying costs, and operating margins. A realtor sale to a retail buyer will generally yield a higher gross sale price — though the net difference narrows significantly once you subtract commissions, repairs, and carrying costs.
Your property will pass a standard inspection.
Buyers who finance their purchase need a lender-approved appraisal and will typically request an inspection. If your home will pass both without major issues, the traditional route works in your favor.
You're comfortable with the process.
Showings, negotiations, contingencies, and the possibility of deals falling through are all part of traditional selling. If you're prepared for that, a good agent can guide you through it.
Bottom line: If your house is in solid shape and you have 90+ days, talk to a local agent. We'll be the first to tell you that.
When Selling to a Cash Buyer Makes More Sense
A direct cash sale is likely the smarter path if:
Your home needs significant repairs.
Foundation issues, roof damage, mold, outdated electrical, code violations — these problems cost $10,000 to $50,000+ to fix before you can list. If your property needs major work, selling as-is to a cash buyer often nets you more after you factor in repair costs, commissions, and months of carrying costs.
You need to sell quickly.
Job relocation, foreclosure, divorce, financial pressure — when time matters, a cash sale that closes in 7 to 30 days solves the problem. Traditional sales simply can't match that timeline.
The property has complications.
Inherited homes in probate, properties with liens or code violations, homes with difficult tenants, properties in condemned status — these situations make traditional sales extremely difficult. Cash buyers like ClearEdge deal with these situations routinely.
You want certainty.
Cash offers don't fall through due to financing, appraisals, or buyer cold feet. Once you accept, the sale is happening. In the traditional market, roughly 1 in 5 deals fall through before closing.
You want zero out-of-pocket costs.
No repairs, no staging, no commissions, no closing costs. The offer is your net.
You value privacy and simplicity.
No public listing, no open houses, no dozens of strangers walking through your home. One point of contact, one clear process.
Let's Do the Math: Cash Sale vs. Traditional in Eastern PA
Want to see numbers for YOUR property? Try our interactive calculator to get a personalized estimate.
3-bedroom in Allentown worth $280,000 after repairs, but needs $35,000 in work
RTraditional Route
CClearEdge Cash Offer
The difference: ~$5,600 — but you saved 5+ months, risked $0 out of pocket, and had zero chance of the deal falling through.
Well-maintained home in Bethlehem worth $320,000 with only $5,000 in cosmetic updates
RTraditional Route
CClearEdge Cash Offer
The difference: ~$31,000 in favor of listing traditionally. This is when we'd tell you to call a realtor.
Note: These examples use estimated figures for illustration based on current Pennsylvania market data. PA average realtor commission is 5.81% (source: Clever/Real Estate Witch agent survey, Sept 2025), PA seller closing costs average 5.33% of sale price. Every property is different — request your free, no-obligation offer for real numbers specific to your situation.
And remember: Scenario A assumes everything goes perfectly with the traditional route. If repairs uncover additional issues, if the buyer's financing falls through, or if the home sits on the market longer than expected — the gap closes or reverses entirely.
Which Selling Method Fits Your Situation?
A cash sale might be right for you if:
- Your property needs more than $10,000 in repairs
- You need to close within 30 days
- The property is inherited, in probate, or has title complications
- You're facing foreclosure or have liens against the property
- You don't want to pay agent commissions or closing costs
- You'd rather not deal with showings, open houses, or negotiations
- The property has tenants you don't want to manage through a sale
- You live out of state and can't oversee repairs or showings
- You want a guaranteed sale with no financing contingencies
- You value speed and simplicity over maximizing every dollar
A traditional listing might be better if:
- Your home is in good, move-in-ready condition
- You have 90+ days before you need to close
- You're willing to invest in repairs and staging upfront
- Maximizing the sale price is your top priority
- Your property will pass a standard buyer's inspection
- You're comfortable with the traditional selling process
If you checked more boxes on the left, a cash offer is worth exploring. If you checked more on the right, a realtor may serve you better. Either way, getting a no-obligation cash offer gives you a real number to compare against — and it costs you nothing.
Get Your Free Cash Offer to CompareNot All Cash Buyers Are Created Equal
The cash home buying industry has legitimate companies and shady operators. Here's what to watch for. For a complete guide on spotting scams and vetting buyers, see our full page on whether cash home buyers are legit.
Red Flags
- They won't show proof of funds
- They pressure you to sign immediately
- They charge "processing fees" or "administrative costs"
- They're not local — they're a national call center
- They won't explain how they calculated the offer
- They don't have Google reviews or a physical presence
- They try to renegotiate the price after you've accepted
What ClearEdge Does Differently
- We show you exactly how we calculate our offer
- We provide proof of funds on request
- Zero fees — ever
- We're a local, family-owned business based in Eastern PA since 2016
- 5.0 Google rating with real, verified reviews
- 30-day offer validity — no rush, no pressure
- Tyler answers the phone: (610) 904-8526
Common Questions About Cash Buyers vs. Realtors
Here are the questions homeowners ask most when deciding how to sell.
Generally, yes — cash offers are below full market value because cash buyers account for repair costs, carrying costs, and their operating margin. However, once you subtract the commissions (5.81% average in Pennsylvania), repair costs ($10K-$50K+), seller closing costs (~2%), and carrying costs from a traditional sale, the net difference is often much smaller than people expect — and sometimes a cash offer actually nets more for homes that need significant work. We break down the real math with two PA-specific examples on this page.
Absolutely. Many homeowners get a cash offer first as a baseline, then decide whether the potential upside of listing is worth the time, cost, and uncertainty. A cash offer from ClearEdge is free and comes with zero obligation.
Check Google reviews, ask for proof of funds, verify they have a local presence, and make sure they can explain exactly how they calculated their offer. If anything feels off, walk away. For a complete guide on spotting scams, see our page on whether cash home buyers are legit.
Legitimate cash buyers make offers based on transparent formulas — after-repair value minus renovation costs, carrying costs, and operating margin. At ClearEdge, we walk you through every number. Our offers are competitive because we buy and hold locally, which means we can often pay more than flippers who need larger margins.
Call us. Seriously. We've referred homeowners to realtors when that was the better path. Our goal is to be helpful, even if that means we're not the right fit. Call Tyler at (610) 904-8526 for an honest conversation about your options.
Yes. We buy homes throughout NEPA, the Lehigh Valley, and the Poconos — 21 communities across Eastern PA.
Still have questions?
We're here to help. Call Tyler directly or reach out.
Find Out What Your House Is Worth in Cash
Answer 5 quick questions. Tyler will personally review your property and send your no-obligation offer within 24 hours.